Can an Employer Withhold Commission If You Quit?
The question of whether an employer can withhold commission if you quit is complex and depends heavily on the specifics of your employment contract, the nature of the commission structure, and applicable laws in your jurisdiction. There's no single, universally applicable answer. However, let's break down the key considerations.
Understanding Commission Structures and Employment Contracts:
The most crucial document is your employment contract. This legally binding agreement outlines the terms of your employment, including your commission structure. Pay close attention to clauses related to:
-
Payment Schedule: Does the contract specify when commissions are paid (e.g., monthly, quarterly, upon completion of a project)? Some contracts stipulate that commissions are earned only upon receipt of payment from the client, while others might grant them upon completion of the sale or service.
-
Earned vs. Payable Commissions: This is a critical distinction. Earned commissions are those you've rightfully accumulated based on your performance, while payable commissions are those that have been officially processed for payment. Many companies hold earned commissions until a set payment period. An employer might be justified in withholding payable commissions that haven't yet fallen due under your contract, but attempting to withhold already earned commissions after your departure could be unlawful.
-
Termination Clauses: This section is paramount. It will detail the conditions under which your employment can be terminated, the notice period required, and any stipulations regarding outstanding payments, including commissions. Look for language specifying whether commissions are payable upon resignation, and under what conditions. If the contract is silent on this issue, it doesn’t automatically grant the employer the right to withhold your commissions.
Common Scenarios and Legal Ramifications:
-
Commissions Earned Before Resignation: Generally, employers cannot legally withhold commissions you've already earned prior to your resignation. If you meet all the contractual requirements to receive payment for those commissions, withholding them would be a breach of contract.
-
Commissions on Ongoing Deals: This is a more nuanced situation. If you initiated a deal before leaving, but the client hasn't paid yet, your employer may argue that you haven't fully earned the commission. The outcome depends significantly on your contract's specifics. Some contracts might stipulate that you receive a portion of the commission, while others might require completion of the sale to earn payment. This is why the “earned vs. payable” distinction is crucial.
-
Commissions for Deals Completed After Resignation: In most cases, unless your contract explicitly states otherwise, you are unlikely to be entitled to commissions on deals completed after your resignation, as you're no longer employed by the company.
-
Unpaid Commissions During Employment: If your employer withheld commissions you were owed during your employment, this is a separate issue that warrants contacting the relevant labor authorities in your jurisdiction.
What to Do If Your Employer Withholds Commissions:
-
Review Your Contract: Carefully reread your employment contract to understand your rights concerning commissions.
-
Gather Documentation: Collect any evidence related to your commission earnings, such as sales reports, client invoices, and emails confirming completed projects.
-
Contact Your Employer: Attempt to resolve the issue amicably by directly contacting your employer and explaining your position.
-
Seek Legal Advice: If negotiations fail, consult with an employment lawyer to discuss your options and legal recourse. They can advise you on whether your employer's actions are legal and how to proceed.
Jurisdictional Differences: Laws governing employment and commission structures vary by location. It's vital to understand the laws in your specific jurisdiction to determine your legal rights.
In conclusion, whether or not an employer can withhold commission when you quit is highly dependent on your individual employment contract and local employment laws. Always consult your contract and, if necessary, seek legal advice to protect your rights.
